Sean corfield, veteran software architect doing clojure in production. I view the most significant application of tail call optimization tco as a translation of a recursive call into a loop in cases in which the recursive call has a certain form. What this recur and tail calls optimization is all about in clojure. In order to do the multiplication, clojurescript has to first figure out what. Do scala and clojure optimize tail calls and tail recursion. It has been built and perfected over the last decade over numerous assignments and engagements. The harmonized standard for medical device software development. Upon execution, the sum of the list elements is 45. Instead, it provides the recur special operator, which does constantspace recursive looping by rebinding and jumping to the nearest enclosing loop or function frame.
While not as general as tailcalloptimization, it allows most of the same. Im learning clojure and decided to do a short screencast on how tail recursion works in clojure. I recently posted an entry in my python history blog on the origins of pythons functional features. Tailrecursive functions are functions in which all recursive calls are tail calls, and thus do not build up any deferred operations. This example shows a program that calls a recursive method. Clojure is impure, yet stands behind the philosophy that programs that are more functional are more robust. A simple implementation of quicksort makes two calls to itself and in worst case requires on space on function call stack. The recursive method x will be called 11 times total.
What limitations does the jvm impose on tailcall optimization. Due to clojures adherence to java calling conventions, clojure is unable to provide full support for constantspace tail calls as is guaranteed by languages like scheme or standard ml. To keep things simple well focus on tail recursion in this post e. By targeting the jvm, clojure gets speedy performance in a cross platform way. If you have a programming background, you may have heard of tail recursion, which is a major feature of functional languages. Do large bindings inside a clojure recursive function harm performance. Why is tail recursion optimisation not implemented in. In practice, lots of algorithms depend on self recursion only but see the ackerman numbers for a standard counter example of a sort they are usually computed with several mutually recursive functions, and since the jvm doesnt support complete tail call optimization, recur represents an elegant compromise between slow, trampoline based full. Similarly, if you have two mutually recursive functions, you can optimize them only by using trampoline the scala compiler is able to perform tco for a recursive function, but not for two mutually recursive functions.
The clojure documentation describes looprecur as a hack so that something like tailrecursiveoptimization works in clojure. Tailcall optimization tco allows programmers to write interesting. Tail calls dont have to add new stack frame to the call stack. It provides the tools to avoid mutable state, provides functions as firstclass objects, and emphasizes recursive iteration instead of sideeffect based looping. In practice, lots of algorithms depend on selfrecursion only but see the ackerman numbers for a standard counter example of a sort they are usually computed with several mutually recursive functions, and since the jvm doesnt support complete tail call optimization, recur represents an elegant compromise between slow, trampoline based full.
Clojure provides the tools to avoid mutable state, provides functions as firstclass objects, and emphasizes recursive iteration instead of sideeffect based looping. Kawa now does general tailcall elimination, but only if you use the flag fulltailcalls. Illustration of recursive function calls call stack. For these cases, optimizing tail recursion remains trivial, but general tail call optimization may be harder to implement efficiently. Its not used so much in a language that lacks tailcall optimisat. Watch this screencast to see how the jetbrains mps plugin for intellij idea can optimize tailrecursive java methods and functions. On tail call optimisation codurance craft at heart london. Evaluates the exprs in order, then, in parallel, rebinds the bindings of the recursion point to the values of the exprs. Clojure is impure, in that it doesnt force your program to be referentially transparent, and doesnt strive for provable programs. Clojure does not perform tail call optimization on its own. Why cant tail calls be optimized in jvmbased lisps. Jvm for clojure, the difficulty is with the jvm that does not support proper tail calls at a low level. Clojure or rather the combination of the compiler and the jvm is indeed smart enough not to allocate constants repeatedly when looping and recurring so there is little risk of running into problems on that account. For those of you who read my previous post on clojure, i decided to look deeper into some recursion methods, and look into the clojure equivalent of lisps tail call optimization tco for those of you, like myself, who dont have much of a functional programming background i remember discussing tco in college in some prolog classes.
Ive been running some test code to see if what ever version of. While not as general as tail call optimization, it. Having the recursion as the very last thing is called tail recursion. Unfortunately, not all platforms support tail call removal, which is necessary for making tail recursion efficient.
The program can then jump to the called subroutine. We have seen the recur statement in an earlier topic and whereas the for loop is somewhat like a loop, recur is a real loop in clojure. Consider this contrived example of a tail recursive program in java. In quicksort, partition function is inplace, but we need extra space for recursive function calls. The clojure quotient does the same thing as pythons floor division. Thoughts about functional programming, startup ideas and more.
General tail call optimization is a complex subject. Eine rekursive funktion f ist endrekursiv englisch tail recursive. While clojure is a lispbased language, it also runs on top of a host virtual machine. A different recursive version, making use of the reductions function. The reason i ask are you sure its tail recursion is that often people think what they have is tail recursive and, it mostly might be, but it has boundary cases or some sort of complexity that makes it nontrivial. Using macros and mutable constructs, its possible to extend the language and give the programmer an immutable and recursive feel. Technically this call could be subject to tail optimization by a compiler. The ability of lisp programs to manipulate themselves is beautiful. If the last operation in a function is a recursive call to that function, then it is easy for the language to treat the operation as a loop. Tail recursion is a kind of recursion that wont blow the stack, so its just about as efficient as a while loop.
Clojure is impure, in that it doesnt force your program to be referentially transparent. I notice a severe halt in the main thread when i try to print to screen 1 to 20,947 as fast as possible. Tail recursion modulo cons is a generalization of tail recursion optimization. A tailrecursive function is just a function whose very the last action is a call to itself. This suggests that tail call optimisation is not available in the jvm, otherwise looprecur would not be needed. See the current language in the link you provided, emphasis added. For parallel and concurrent programming clojure provides software transactional memory, a reactive agent system, and channelbased concurrent programming. We talk about what it is and how to do it, even if your language doesnt support it. Why does the jvm still not support tailcall optimization. Quicksort tail call optimization reducing worst case. In computer science, a tail call is a subroutine call performed as the final action of a procedure. If you are a computer scientist, you must be knowing what recursion is.
You may find other jvm languages are able to optimize tail recursion better try clojure which requires the recur to tail call optimize, or. Do programmers and software engineers use recursion. One of the problems with targeting the jvm with a dynamic language that relies heavily on recursion is that the jvm doesnt support tail recursion also called tail call optimization. On tail call optimisation codurance craft at heart. To the general question of methods to avoid a stack overflow in a recursive algorithm. An article about how to implement tail recursive tree traversal, so that tail call optimization can be done by the compiler. First off, we need to differentiate between tailcalls and tailrecursion.
Leading some people early in clojure s popularity to claim that recur offered a magical solution to the lack of tail call optimization on the jvm but i digress. Is the benefit purely syntactic or does the library offer some kind of performance advantage over doing the trampoline yourself. The concept of closures may seem hard to grasp, but in fact, they arent a rocket science. Clojure programmingexampleslazy fibonacci wikibooks. A side remark about not supporting tail recursion elimination tre immediately sparked several comments about what a pity it is that python doesnt do this, including links to recent blog entries by others trying to prove that tre can be added to. To get around this problem clojure provides the loop recur form. The looprecur construct achieves this, but its implementation is in the. Schemeclojure style recursive looping and tailcall optimization with underscore. Real tco works for arbitrary calls in tail position, not just self calls, so that. Optimization of tail recursive code is a sweet, sweet by product of this. Automatic tail call optimization is not supported as the jvm does not support it natively. If i could first refer you to this question on quora. It is a function calling itself multiple times until certain edge condition is reached. For example, in the java virtual machine jvm, tailrecursive calls can be eliminated as this reuses the existing call stack, but general tail calls cannot be as this changes the call stack.
Expanding support for constantspace tail calls in the clojure language. Clojure can translate seemingly recursive code into a loop. Given that some recursive cases act as loops, we can optimize them by turning them into loops behind the scenes. This blog post is trying to give a short yet easy to remember explanation. Recur only optimises recursive tailcalls to the function you are in, tco generally implies that any tailcalls recursive or not can be optimised including mutually recursive calls, for which clojure made the trampoline function or just calling one function at the tail of another. First, the thing you want is tail call optimization. Since clojure uses the java calling conventions, it cannot, and does not, make the same tail call optimization guarantees. It features usage of a stack to make a recursive algorithm capable of tail recursion. Tail call optimisation is very important for functional programming, but what exactly is. There are different issues at play for the various languages.
The pillars of functional programming part 2 sigma. Also its worth noting that clojure, because of limitations of the jvm, doesnt support automatic tail call optimization. Tail call optimization in java is hard and depends on the jvm. So to make things a bit more clear, lets assume that our. Now, i dont know much about clojure and little about scala, but ill give it a shot. Currently, the eval function itself is not fully tailrecursive, in violation of r5rs.
The same code in a tail recursive style might look like the following. Im not sure that the python interpreter is making this optimization, but i dont know what youre looking at. Suppose function1 calls function2, and function2 calls function3. Given that some recursive cases act as loops, we can optimize them by turning them.
Knolway is a knoldus proprietary process to develop highquality software. Which programming languages support tail recursion. Using parenthec to transform scheme programs to c or how to write interesting recurive programs in a spartan host program. Clojure tail call optimizer ctco an embedded sourcetosource compiler for clojure that provides the benefit of full tailcall optimization tco to clojure code. Recently i came to know about amazing concept of tail recursion optimization. With that general idea in mind, lets look at an example and see how it gets optimized. This is the continuation of the topic from the pillars of functional programming part 1, proceeding with the consequences of treating the functions as a firstclass type o firstclass functions, the aftermath. Quicksort tail call optimization reducing worst case space to log n.
927 302 276 1510 215 255 139 1104 1335 336 246 84 1309 1435 1529 961 1397 1248 953 1551 512 4 613 174 636 1113 1489 700 581 796 891 379